Christmas Mysteries at The Mysterious Bookshop
By Otto Penzler
First published 2026
Eighteen puzzling Christmas tales set in New York City’s beloved mystery bookstore In 1993, The Mysterious Bookshop—the oldest mystery specialty bookstore in the world—began an annual tradition by inviting bestselling author Donald E. Westlake to write an original short story set in the bookshop during the holiday season. Each year since then, The Mysterious Bookshop commissions a new short story from a leading author to give out as a holiday gift for its customers. The prompt for the story requires three elements: that it be set at Christmastime, that it involve a crime of some kind, or the suspicion of one, and that it be set at least partially in the bookstore. Beyond these guidelines, authors had free rein to take the story in whatever direction they chose. This volume collects the first eighteen stories commissioned by the bookshop from 1993 to 2010. Included are tales by Megan Abbott, Rupert Holmes, Mary Higgins Clark, Andrew Klavan, and Ed McBain, plus an updated introduction by Mysterious Bookshop proprietor Otto Penzler. Some of the stories are humorous, others thrilling, and still others are takes of pure detection.
- Published
- 8 Sep 2026
- Pages
- 408
- Publisher
- The Mysterious Press
- Edition
- Hardcover
- Elsewhere
- Open Library
- Mystery
- Thriller
How members shelved it
Nobody has logged this yet.
More by Otto Penzler
If you liked this
Brain Damage
2016
Also thriller and mystery
Exit Party - A Novel
2026
Also thriller and mystery
Yesteryear A Novel
2026
Also thriller and mystery
The Da Vinci Code
2003
Also thriller and mystery
Mad Mabel
2027
Also thriller and mystery
The Housemaid
2022
Also thriller and mystery
The Secret History
1992
Also thriller and mystery
The Green Mile
1996
Also thriller and mystery









