Finding Nicole Morin

On July 30, 1985, a then eight-year-old Nicole Morin reportedly left her top-floor apartment on The West Mall in Etobicoke to meet a friend for a swim. She was never seen again. Nicole’s disappearance marked one of the largest and most extensive searches in Toronto police’s history. Now, police are offering a new $50,000 reward for anyone with information about her disappearance.

The show’s own verdict is on its page.